Mark Wahlberg as Pete Wagner

Rose Byrne as Ellie Wagner

Allyn Rachel as Kim

Isabela Merced as Elizabeth “Lizzy” Viara

Julie Hagerty as Jan

Tig Notaro as Sharon

Octavia Spencer as Karen

Gustavo Escobar as Juan Viara

Margo Martindale as Sandy Wagner

Julianna Gamiz as Lita Viara

Tom Segura as Russ

Britt Rentschler as Linda

Michael O'Keefe as Jerry

Jody Thompson as Jim

Iliza Shlesinger as October Ross Jennings

Gary Weeks as Dirk McCann

Joy Jacobson as Dana McCann

Hampton Fluker as Kit

Randy Havens as Michael

Andrea Anders as Jessie

Kenneth Israel as David

Joan Cusack as Mrs. Howard

Valente Rodriguez as Judge Rivas

Carson Holmes as Charlie

Jaiden Byrd as Young Brian

Connor Jones as Young Pete

James Arthur Sims as Brian's Dad

Rosemary Dominguez as Mrs. Fernandez

Javier Ronceros as Mr. Fernández

Eve Harlow as Brenda Fernandez

Nicholas Logan as Jacob

Charlie McDermott as Stewart

Joselin Reyes as Carla

Erika Bierman as Kylie

Sarah Kirkpatrick as Kimberly

Maureen Brennan as Mrs. Muskie

Kelly Tippens as Miss Peppers

John McConnell as Mr. Muskie

Layla Felder as Savannah

Allen Zwolle as Principal

Stella Doyle as Ms. Franks

Andrene Ward-Hammond as Sue

Remy Ortiz as Random Dad

William J. Simmons as Lita's Classmate

Denitra Isler as Bailiff

Anthony "Ace" Thomas as Cop

Candice Daniels as Nurse

Alexis Lord as Soccer Girl

Perry Westberry as Doctor

Maegan McCarthy as Kindergarten Teacher

Jerry T. Richerson as Student

Billie Wilemon as Emergency Room Nurse

Cruze Lynnox Keith as Lita's Classmate

Caleb Pratt as Student

Jonathan Kobs as Roberto C. Fishman Pratt