Justin Rose as Ben

Kelly Curran as Allyson

Rocco Guirlanda as Professor Nolan Gallagher

Seraphina Anne Zorn as Jennifer

Shelby Brunn as Grace

Deacon Hayward as Puppy Love Boy

Louis Badalament as Shakespearean Professor

Jeremy Kaluza as Teen Boyfriend

Charlie Hunt as Horse-Head Man

Jon W. Martin as Ben Senior

Christy Edwards as Tracy

Amy Drohan as Girl in Movie

Katelyn Kabel as Romantic Girl

Howard Farmer as Rude Customer

Sarah Dean as Student at Comedy Club #3

Anna Bauman as Engineering Student

Joel Bradley as Student with Sandwich

Megan Fluharty as Female Street Musician

Lissa Strodtbeck as Mom #1

Treasheer D. Allison as Woman at Bar

Zach Barber as Max from High School

Jordan Borges as Teen Girlfriend

Satin Quiroz as Student at Comedy Club #2

Robert Busha as Blind Customer

Jacari Britton as Comedy Club MC

Katherine Tasma as Student at Comedy Club #1

Logan Hurtado as Rebound Date

Stacy Hayward as Mom #2

Joseph Cassidy as Cinema Employee

John Strodtbeck as Dad #1

Elisha Gidron as Hat Store Clerk

Kasey Palmer as Mother in Audience

Brianna Buller as Student at Comedy Club #4

Tyler Thorne as Street Guitarist

Derek Hiler as Male Street Musician

Ryan Warriner as Lonely Guy

Nicholas Hayward as Dad #2

Gillian Strodtbeck as Puppy Love Girl

Jason Brophy as Horse-Head Man's Buddy

Dan Faultersack as Waiter

Steven Owsley as Stand-Up Comedian

Justin Lundy as Fry Cook / Bartender

Riley Ellis as Girl in Audience

James Stump as Romantic Guy

DeJuan Bland as Stage Actor