Bette Davis as Libby Strong

Lillian Gish as Sarah Webber

Vincent Price as Mr. Maranov

Ann Sothern as Tisha Doughty

Harry Carey, Jr. as Joshua Brackett

Margaret Ladd as Young Libby

Mary Steenburgen as Young Sarah

Tisha Sterling as Young Tisha

Frank Grimes as Mr. Beckwith

Frank Pitkin as Old Randall

Mike Bush as Young Randall