Victoria Anastasi as 20 year old Kate

Carter Babcock as 10 year old Josh

Elizabeth Becka as Older Alice

Les Best as 50 year old Ronnie

Jaden Bishop as 14 Year old Josh

Dave Blamy as Pastor

Emma Dison Brantley as 13 year old Faith

Jason Rhymer as Older Rick

Garry Nation as Older Charlie

Joseph Curtis Callender as Kenneth

Anisa Nyell Johnson as Teresa

Dawson R. Shea as 15-year-old Ronnie

Justin Livingston as 18-year-old Ronnie

Elliana Papageorgiou as 12-year-old Kate

Katherine Shepler as 15-year-old Kate

Frances Dell Bendert as 47-year-old Kate

Alex Kendrick as 42-year-old Josh

Tara Warolin as 40-year-old Kate

Micah Drew Johnson as

Kathleen Dellinger as Susan

Joel Dellinger as Christopher