Andrew Garfield as Jonathan Larson

Alexandra Shipp as Susan Wilson

Robin de Jesús as Michael

Michaela Jaé Rodriguez as Carolyn

Ben Levi Ross as Freddy

Jonathan Marc Sherman as Ira Weitzman

Vanessa Hudgens as Karessa Johnson

Joshua Henry as Roger Bart

Bradley Whitford as Stephen Sondheim

Judith Light as Rosa Stevens

Laura Benanti as Judy

Danielle Ferland as Kim

Micaela Diamond as Peggy

Utkarsh Ambudkar as Todd

Gizel Jiménez as Cristin

Kate Rockwell as Lauren

Aneesa Folds as Danya

Joel Perez as Lincoln

Anna A. Louizos as Michelle

Robyn Goodman as Gay

Judy Kuhn as Nan

Danny Burstein as Al

Lauren Marcus as Donna

Richard Kind as Walter Bloom

Tariq Trotter as H.A.W.K. Smooth

Janet Dacal as Sextet Actor #1

Kenita R. Miller as Sextet Actor #2

Eddy Lee as Sextet Actor #3

Jared Loftin as Sextet Actor #4

Kurt Crowley as Rehearsal Pianist - Francis

Ryan Vasquez as Scott

Joanna Adler as Molly

Sheila Tapia as Nurse

Ricardo Zayas as Hospital Man #1

Travis Patton as Hospital Man #2

Christopher Jackson as TTB Concert Attendee

Jelani Alladin as David

Andrew Bancroft as Building Parking Attendant

Chris Sullivan as Building Doorman

Luis A. Miranda Jr. as Building Concierge

Kelly Watson as Homeless Person

Chuck Cooper as "Sunday" Legend #1

André De Shields as "Sunday" Legend #2

Renée Elise Goldsberry as "Sunday" Legend #3

Joel Grey as "Sunday" Legend #4

Wilson Jermaine Heredia as "Sunday" Legend #5

Beth Malone as "Sunday" Legend #6

Howard McGillin as "Sunday" Legend #7

Brian Stokes Mitchell as "Sunday" Legend #8

Bebe Neuwirth as "Sunday" Legend #9

Adam Pascal as "Sunday" Legend #10

Bernadette Peters as "Sunday" Legend #11

Phylicia Rashād as "Sunday" Legend #12

Chita Rivera as "Sunday" Legend #13

Daphne Rubin-Vega as "Sunday" Legend #14

Phillipa Soo as "Sunday" Legend #15

Chad Beguelin as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Nick Blaemire as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Eli Bolin as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Jason Robert Brown as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Eisa Davis as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Amanda Green as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Quiara Alegría Hudes as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Joe Iconis as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Tom Kitt as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Alex Lacamoire as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Steven Levenson as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Jaime Lozano as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Dave Malloy as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Matthew McCollum as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Grace McLean as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Helen Park as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Stephen Schwartz as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Marc Shaiman as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Matthew Sklar as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Georgia Stitt as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Shaina Taub as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Jeanine Tesori as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Stephen Trask as Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Sean McDaniel as TTB Band Member #1 - Drums

Victoria Theodore as TTB Band Member #2 - Keyboards

Bryndon Cook as TTB Band Member #3 - Guitar

Debbie Tjong as TTB Band Member #4 - Electric Guitar

Charles Conforti as Young Jon

Derrick Delgado as Young Michael

Mason Versaw as Teenage Jon

Javiel Sellas as Teenage Michael

Barbara Ames as Music Teacher

James C. Nicola as Featured Diner #1

Roger Bart as Featured Diner #2

Emily Juean Stillings as Susan Company Dancer #1

Jennifer Laroche as Susan Company Dancer #2

Lauren Yalango-Grant as Susan Company Dancer #3

Ayo Jackson as Susan Company Dancer #4

Lucy Struever as Susan Company Dancer #5

Stephanie Crousillat as Susan Company Dancer #6

Gaby Diaz as Susan Company Dancer #7

Ilia Jessica Castro as "PLAY GAME" Dancer #1

Marie Rose Baramoski as "PLAY GAME" Dancer #2

Keisha 'Sparkle' Hughes as "PLAY GAME" Dancer #3

Lane Napper as Bookstore Dancer #1

Kyle McIntire as Bookstore Dancer #2

Sean Ryan as Bookstore Dancer #3

Christopher Grant as "SUNDAY" Busboy Dancer #1

Austin Goodwin as "SUNDAY" Busboy Dancer #2

Carlos Gonzalez as "SUNDAY" Cook Dancer

Elizabeth Chestang as Lobby Dancer #1

Callan Bergmann as Lobby Dancer #2

Kyle Richard Robinson as Lobby Dancer #3

Erin N. Moore as Lobby Dancer #4

Taeler Cyrus as Lobby Dancer #5

Spencer Clark as Lobby Dancer #6

Ehizoje Azeke as Lobby Dancer #7

Chloe N. Crade as Lobby Dancer #8

Maira Barriga Toyama as Lobby Dancer #9

Christine Seinicki as Lobby Dancer #10

Purdie Baumann as Lobby Dancer #11

Erin Monteleone as Lobby Dancer #12

Noah Lentini as HS West Side Dancer #1

Jacob Patrick Wasson as HS West Side Dancer #2

Adriel Flete as HS West Side Dancer #3

Dwany Guzman as HS West Side Dancer #4

Victoria Caban as HS West Side Dancer #5

Melody Rose as HS West Side Dancer #6

Alexia Belrose as HS West Side Dancer #7

Lin-Manuel Miranda as Diner Manager (uncredited)

Stephen Sondheim as Stephen Sondheim (voice on phone) (uncredited)

Ken Holmes as YMCA Poolgoer (uncredited)

Jonathan Larson as Self (archive footage) (uncredited)