Noah Segan as Truman

Melora Walters as Maria

Zachary Knighton as Duncan

Stan Shaw as Lester

Bill Sage as Dodd

James Landry Hébert as Cotton Mather

Devin Druid as Jake

Natasha Bassett as Pearl

Pat Healy as Wylie

Tina Parker as Brenda

Alexandra Harris as Etta

Jonny Mars as Vernon

Jake Ryan Scott as Young Duncan

Darryl Cox as Barkeep

Mark Adam Goff as Outlaw

Danielle Evon Ploeger as Nellie

Holt Boggs as Allan

Peggy Schott as Opal

Doug Van Liew as Earl

Collin Place as Buck

Jeremy King as Bill Buckley

Debbi Tucker as Witch

Kent Shelton as Pinkerton Detective

Erin Herring as Townswoman

Seth Stuart as Man with Flask

Alex Atkinson as Train Passenger