Chyler Leigh as Queenie

Matt Czuchry as Jordan

Alexia Fast as Five

Jeff Hephner as Hiram

Patrick Garrow as The Prophet

Lara Jean Chorostecki as Ann Eliza

Patricia Wettig as BeckyLyn

Sarain Boylan as Desert Missy

John Bourgeois as Brigham Young

David Lawrence Brown as Mr. Heber (as Dave Brown)

Karl Pruner as Sawyer Scott

Brian Jensen as Cop

Peter Strand Rumpel as Chauncey

Dan Baziuk as Sheriff

Vanessa Holmes as Kimberly Scott

Malia Ashley Kerr as Angela Alton (as Malia Kerr)

Justin Michael Carriere as Gilbert Webb (as Justin Michael Carrier)

Holly Turner as Mrs. Hagen

Barbara Gates Wilson as Elizabeth

Brian Copping as Judge Hagen

Idan Wolach as Young Jordan

Kelly Hoare as Morman Man

Darryl Stogre as Rancher (uncredited)