Chazz Palminteri as Paul Castellano

Clancy Brown as Andris Kurins

Angela Alvarado as Gloria Olarte

Jay O. Sanders as Joseph O'Brien

Daniel Benzali as Bruce Mouw

Richard Foronjy as Tommy Bilotti

Mark Margolis as Piney Armone

Steven Bauer as Vito Genovese

Patricia Mauceri as Nina Castellano

Vince Corazza as Philip Castellano

Angelo Tucci as Paul Castellano Jr.

Tony Nappo as Gene Gotti

Sonny Marinelli as John Gotti

Philip Williams as Nino Gaggi

Yani Gellman as Young Paul Castellano

William DeMeo as Young Carlo Gambino

James Villani as Young Neil Dellacroce

Karen Goberman as Young Nina Manno

Louis Di Bianco as Joey Bazzini

James Downing as Agent Bledsoe

Michael A. Miranda as Roy DeMeo

Dominic Cuzzocrea as Stanza

Vito Rezza as Angelo Ruggerio

Vince Corazza as Joe Castellano

Gerry Mendicino as Father Vicente

Layton Morrison as Sacco Tambone

Reagan Pasternak as NYU Student

Lucy Filippone as Mott Street Woman

Renato Rizzuti as Marco

Ron Gabriel as Tommy Agro

Peter Haworth as Agent Riley

John Alcorn as Lounge Singer

Al Ruscio as Carlo Gambino

Gino Marrocco as Carmine 'The Snake' Persico

Tony Perri as Anthony 'Fat Tony' Salerno

Nikki Pascetta as Concetta Castellano

Brian Smiar as Jimmy Malone

Tim MacMenamin as Frankie Toole

Michael Proudfoot as Sean Collins

Michael Kinney as Assistant D.A.

Betti Orsatti as Old Lady Customer

J.C. Kenny as Reporter #1