Justin Long as Frank

Tommy Flanagan as Aeolus

Katia Winter as Natalie

Donald Faison as Jeff

Sheila Vand as Theresa

Sarah Minnich as Cheryl

Bill Sage as Jonas

Monique Candelaria as Olive

Ronnie Gene Blevins as Ritchie

Blythe Howard as Jessica Warren

Carl W. Lucas as Big Jesus

Jocelyn Montoya as Not Theresa

Guia Peel as Asian Woman

Alexander Alayon Jr. as Naked Man (as Alexander Alayon)