Kate Micucci as Claire

Sam Huntington as Paul

Taika Waititi as Storsh

Dan Harmon as Cartwright

Mark McKinney as Cultist

Rhea Seehorn as Nordheim

Dana Gould as Pearl

Maria Bamford as Cultist

Brian Posehn as Cultist

Lilan Bowden as Anthea

Jon Dore as Tony

Mindy Sterling as Beatrice

Josh Brener as Cultist

J. Lee as Stone

Brian Girard as Wallace

Michael St. Michaels as Cultist

Matt Jones as Phil

Ryan Simpkins as Cultist

Britney Young as Cultist

Craig Cackowski as Golfer

Ron Lynch as Cultist

John Yuan as Cultist

Matt Yuan as Cultist

Lola Kelly as Cultist

Adam Brodie as Cultist

John J. Lozada as The Mascot

Robert Evans as Armund Nordheim