Marla Sokoloff as Lindsey Scott

Rob Mayes as Wes Bailey

Marie Osmond as Cassie

Jan Broberg Felt as Aunt Maggie

Jacob Young as Mark

Whitney Palmer as Allie

Anna Daines as Marilyn

Melanie Haynes as Gwen

Eliza de Azevedo Brown as Monica

Taunya Gren as Wes' Mom

Nikolas Mikkelsen as Street performer / Concert attendee

Clotile Yanna as Erica

Jill Adler as Innkeeper

Jerome Brad Halgren as Christmas Pageant Attendee

Brian Robinson as Robby

Jonez Cain as Lady #2

Kenneth Cummins as Tyler

Laurie Harrop-Purser as Sister Catherine

Cat Hammons as Lady #1

Charlie Stover as Kid Narrator

Sage Pederson as Kid Angel

Carlie Young as Waitress

David Stanley as Ticket Salesperson