Jeffrey Dean Morgan as Gerry Fenn

Cricket Brown as Alice

William Sadler as Father Hagan

Katie Aselton as Natalie Gates

Cary Elwes as Bishop Gyles

Diogo Morgado as Delgarde

Bates Wilder as Geary

Marina Mazepa as Mary of Elnor

Christine Adams as Monica Slade

Dustin Tucker as Dan Walsh

Gisela Chípe as Sophia Walsh

Danny Corbo as Toby Walsh

Sonny Corbo as Toby Walsh

Michael Strauss as Max

Madison LaPlante as Faithful Teen Girl

Doria Bramante as Waitress

Stephen O'Neil Martin as Atheist Man

Tim Estiloz as Correspondent

Ted Wayman as Correspondent

Andrea Athanassiou as Internet Woman

Hannah Jane Doyon as Internet Woman

Celeste Oliva as Librarian

Chris Byers as Shopkeeper

Mere Davis as Faithful #1

Dave Heard as Faithful #2

Kiara Pichardo as Faithful #3

Kevin Fennessy as Faithful #4

Charlie Thurston as Nervous Man Leaving Town

Mike Wendt as Blacksmith

Lisa Gresci as Journalist

Bill Thorpe as Father Prescott

Lorna Larkin as Mary Elnor (voice)

Cassidy Neal as Grace Father (uncredited)

Rob Lévesque as City Official (uncredited)

J.J. Wright as Talk Show Host (uncredited)

Adrian M. Mompoint as Camera Crew (uncredited)

Jonathan Neves as Church Goer (uncredited)

Nicholas Trotto as Church Member (uncredited)