Lacey Chabert as Tess Harper

Brennan Elliott as Logan O'Connor

Barbara Niven as Aunt Candace

John Kapelos as Chief Chauncey O'Connor

Genevieve Kang as Josephine

Steve Belford as Reed

Noam Jenkins as The Amazing Alistair

Kaitlyn Leeb as Bianca

Paulino Nunes as Rocco

Matthew Gouveia as Cormac

Cynthia Preston as Julia Marquez

Romaine Waite as Winston Sams

Boomer Phillips as Delivery Man

Will Shortz as Will

Chris Handfield as Paul Drexler

Nigel Downer as Dr. Cohen

Milton Barnes as Coroner's Clerk

Trudy Weiss as Maude

Jill Frappier as Tamara

Darryl Hinds as Antiques Dealer

Jim Calarco as Landlord