Monica Knox as Alison

Michael Morrone as Brock

Caylin Turner as Traci

Stacey Bernstein as Chief Jane

Celestine Caravaggio as Yolanda

Brian Scott Carleton as Saul

Michelle Shaughnessy as Heather

Diana Chrisman as Candace

Mark Ettlinger as Barry

Madeline Leon as Nurse

Sloane Long as Angel

Katrina Parag as Church-Goer

Rebecca Perry as Jemma

Lily Ro as Jess

Callum Thompson as Han

Hugh Wilson as Father Mitchell

Naiya Novak as Child in Nativity pageant (uncredited)