B.J. Novak as Ben Manalowitz

Boyd Holbrook as Ty Shaw

J. Smith-Cameron as Sharon Shaw

Issa Rae as Eloise

Ashton Kutcher as Quentin Sellers

Lio Tipton as Abilene Shaw

Dove Cameron as Kansas City Shaw

Isabella Amara as Paris Shaw

Eli Bickel as El Stupido Shaw

John Mayer as John

Louanne Stephens as Granny Carole Shaw

Zach Villa as Sancholo

Clint Obenchain as Crawl

Rio Alexander as Sheriff Jimenez

Ryan Hammond as Det. Keith St. John

Ben Whitehair as Officer Dan

Grayson Berry as Officer Mike

Nathaniel Augustson as Rowdy Stranger #1

Sean J. Dillingham as Rowdy Stranger

Ivan Hernandez as Sancholo's Thug

David Hight as Cowboy

Tracy S. Lee as Radio Intern

Adrianne Lovato as Texan Line Dancer

Micah McNeil as Texas Tech Fan

Mike Miller as Doctor

Sarah Minnich as

Bronwen Murray as Hipster

Aaron Rogers as NYC Hipster

Tony Sedillo as Sancholo's Associate

J. Nathan Simmons as Diner Patron

Avalon Stone as Whataburger Waitress

Dora Woodrum as Artist / Original Artwork

Darlene Kellum as Dancer (uncredited)

Gonzalo Robles as Not Sancholo (uncredited)

Jeremy Warner as Club Patron (uncredited)

Melissa Chambers as (uncredited)