Chris Pine as Luther Scott

Cameron Daddo as Father Michael Kelly

Bruce Davison as Father Thomas Parker

Tom Bosley as Father Abbot Sutton

Peter Greene as Detective William Fletcher

Lukas Behnken as Robbie Willingham

Travis Van Winkle as Scott

Kate Vernon as Detective Robin Mallory

Janet Carroll as Mother Superior

Robert Pine as Senator Givens

Adam Bussell as David Bennet

Evan Ellingson as Benjamin Givens

Nick Fowler as Frank Kelly

Ramon Hilario as Mr. Rios

Kathy Lamkin as Marie

Stephen Sowan as Joseph

Bob Rumnock as Father Jordan

Craig Shoemaker as Father Charles

Wiley M. Pickett as Dean Kelly

Branden Morgan as Riley

Fred Meyers as Matt

Daniel Kountz as Malachi