Oona Chaplin as Rachel

Ramón Rodríguez as John

Liane Balaban as Vivian

Moni Ogunsuyi as Clerk

Austin Ball as Aaron

Brian McCaig as Benny

Kira Guloien as Lilith

Adam Bernett as Shomrim #1

Hayden Finkelshtain as Shomrim #2

Mark Reinhardt as Young Man

Sasha Rajamani as FedEx Delivery Guy

Mary Ann Stevens as Crone

Julie Khaner as Rabbi Simowitz

Alex Karzis as Rabbi Cohen

Spencer MacPherson as Stevie