Jane Higginson as Sarah Quinn

Tracy Fraim as Noah Adams

Brian Bremer as Pino

William Thorne as Derek

Neith Hunter as Kim

Amy L. Taylor as Merideth

Eric Welch as Buck

Van Quattro as Tom Quinn

Clint Howard as Ricky

Gerry Black as Harold

Conan Yuzna as Lonnie

Mickey Rooney as Joe Petto

Thornton Simmons as Other Santa

Catherine Schreiber as Mother

Zoe Yuzna as Brandy

Jennifer Pusheck as Elf

Billy Oscar as Dad

Cathy Yuzna as Stroller #1

Gary Schmoeller as Stroller #2

Richard N. Gladstein as Driver Dad

Jan Linder as Nurse