Chord Overstreet as Tom

Olivia Culpo as Laura Jane

Luke Wilson as Lance

Aleksander Vayshelboym as Ricky

Adelaide Kane as Georgia

Matt McCoy as Manfred

E.E. Bell as Papa McGursky

Carolyn Hennesy as Mama McGursky

Maria Breese as Marie

Jon Lovitz as Jon Johnson

Carl Davis as Island Man

Leslie Stratton as Molly

Joshua Uduma as Father Tyrone

Boni Mata as Anna

Hayley Amber Smith as Natasha

Linda Purl as Sherry Fairfax-Rothstein

Dot-Marie Jones as Finley

Natalia Janoszek as Lifeguard

Oliver Cooper as Ira

Jessica Uberuaga as Mandy

Eric Michael Cole as Father Michael

Autumn Adele as Autumn

Paul Piercy as Consultant

Lola Sandra as Lola (as Lola Akinola)

King Orba as Howard Freeman

Eva Hamilton as Irene