Janel Parrish as Melody Knapp

Jeremy Jordan as Adam Yeager

Marisol Nichols as Nina

Sadie Coleman as Holly

Piper Rubio as Ivy

Anne Sward as Patricia

Nova Patten as Kayla

Jon Stafford as Warren

Carrie Morgan as Christine

Ashli Auguillard as Gwen

Terence Goodman as Ed

Tamari Dunbar as Elena

Darin Southam as Brian

Charla Bocchicchio as Harried Librarian

Annette Ciavarella as Bailiff

Bryce Fernelius as Enthusiastic Librarian

Chantel Flanders as Charlie

Cat Hammons as Bernice

Adriane McLean as Kimberly Dade

Alireza Mirmontazeri as Party Guest

Rae Serbeck as Hardwood Store Bag Carrier