Danielle Panabaker as Katie Lapp

Sherry Stringfield as Laura Mayfield-Bennett

Sarah Maine as Jessica

Willie Stratford as Theodore

Jason Loughlin as Benjamin Lapp

Sandra Elise Williams as Rebecca Lapp

Bill Oberst Jr. as Samuel Lapp

Wyatt Lanier as Jacob Beiler

Burgess Jenkins as Bishop John Beiler

Dalton Parrish as Hickory John Beiler

David Topp as Daniel Fisher

Richard Fullerton as Ephram Yoder

Nancy Saunders as Ella Mae Zook

Rachel St. Gelais as Benjamin's Daughter

Jana Allen as Amanda

Sarah E. Chambers as Mary Stoltzfus

Jimmy Hager as Preacher Yoder

David Forrester as Amish Elder

Scott Helms as Amish Man

Robert C. Treveiler as Surgeon

Stephen West-Rogers as Trauma Nurse

Lee Freeman as Nurse Rosie

Alexa Yeames as Young Laura

Tim Holt as Dylan Bennett

Michele Lee as Store Clerk

Lindsey Moser as Nurse (uncredited)