Jason Biggs as Anderson

Isla Fisher as Katie

Michael Weston as Ted

Ebon Moss-Bachrach as Matador

Joe Pantoliano as Smitty

Heather Goldenhersh as Jane

Joanna Gleason as Lois

Edward Herrmann as Lyle

Margo Martindale as Betsy

Mark Consuelos as Morty

Audra Blaser as Vanessa

Matt Malloy as Stuart

Rob Corddry as Kyle

Jay O. Sanders as Sheriff

Chris Diamantopoulos as William

Kevin Allison as Hal

Roger Robinson as Dr. Favreau

Teodorina Bello as Rhonda

Regan Mizrahi as Diner Kid

Chuck Ardezzone as Scary-Looking Con

Andrea Rosen as Woman on Bus

Robert Trebor as Rabbi Feldman

Edwin Freeman as Police Officer