Angela Mariano as Sarah

Rick Edwards as Father Jake

Greg Sestero as David

Louisa Torres as Erika

Jesse Brenneman as Scott

Kristen StephensonPino as Jane

Zhubin Rahbar as Sam

Tom Franco as Brooks

Chris Seidman as Truman

R.J. Cantu as Border Patrol

Sananda Vietor as Motorcyclist

Hannah Mouton as Cher

Alison Skiadas as Voice on Phone / News Anchor

Jessica Cobb as Silver Pines Nurse

Björgvin Franz Gíslason as News Reporter

Cindy Owensby as Woman in Church #1

Coralie Jean Philipe as Woman in Church #2

Tom Franco as Cult Member

Aaron Hart as Cult Member

Benjamin Tarshish as Cult Member

Ethan Tarshish as Cult Member

Jeremy Ambler as Cult Member

Jen Figueroa as Cult Member

Jordan Figueroa as Cult Member