Calvin Lee Reeder as Gary (segment "Tape 56")

Lane Hughes as Zak (segment "Tape 56")

Kentucker Audley as Rox (segment "Tape 56")

Adam Wingard as Brad (segment "Tape 56")

Simon Barrett as Steve (segment "Tape 56")

Andrew Droz Palermo as Fifth Thug (segment "Tape 56")

Joe Swanberg as Sam (segment "Second Honeymoon")

Sophia Takal as Stephanie (segment "Second Honeymoon")

Kate Lyn Sheil as The Stalker (segment "Second Honeymoon")

Hannah Fierman as Lily (segment "Amateur Night")

Mike Donlan as Shane (segment "Amateur Night")

Joe Sykes as Patrick (segment "Amateur Night")

Drew Sawyer as Clint (segment "Amateur Night")

Jasper Lewis as Lisa (segment "Amateur Night")

Nicholas Tecosky as Bartender (segment "Amateur Night")

Lisa Marie Thomas as Lisa's Friend (segment "Amateur Night")

Rob Mosca as Bouncer (segment "Amateur Night")

Chad Villella as Chad (segment "10/31/98")

Matt Bettinelli-Olpin as Matt (segment "10/31/98")

Tyler Gillett as Tyler (segment "10/31/98")

Paul Natonek as Paul (segment "10/31/98")

Nicole Erb as The Girl (segment "10/31/98")

John Walcutt as Cult Leader (segment "10/31/98")

Bilal Mir as Cult Dude (segment "10/31/98")

Damion Stephens as Cult Dude (segment "10/31/98")

Koz McRae as Cult Dude (segment "10/31/98")

Eric Curtis as Eric (segment "10/31/98")

Nicole Boccumini as Niky (segment "10/31/98")

Melinda Fleming as Melinda (segment "10/31/98")

Drew Moerlein as Joey Brenner (segment "Tuesday the 17th")

Jason Yachanin as Spider (segment "Tuesday the 17th")

Norma C. Quinones as Wendy (segment "Tuesday the 17th")

Glenn McQuaid as Victim in River (segment "Tuesday the 17th")

Liz Harvey as The New Girl (segment "The Sick Thing That Happened To Emily When She Was Younger")

Helen Rogers as Emily

Daniel Kaufman as James