Damien Echols as Self

Jessie Misskelley Jr. as Self

Jason Baldwin as Self

Pam Hobbs as Self – Stevie Branch's Mother

Steve Jones as Self – Former Juvenile Officer, Crittenden County

John Fogleman as Self – Former Deputy Prosecutor

Jerry Driver as Self – Former Juvenile Corrections Officer

Sharon French as Self – Juror #9 - Echols/Baldwin Trial

Lorri Davis as Self – Damien's Wife

Mara Leveritt as Self – Author - "Devil's Knot"

Martin Hill as Self – Case Researcher

Dan Stidham as Self – Defense Attorney for Jessie Misskelley

Jessie Misskelley Sr. as Self – Jessie's Father

Steve Drizin as Self – Law Professor, Northwestern Univ. School of Law

Laura Nirider as Self – Staff Attorney, Center on Wrongful Convictions of Youth

Kiki Daire as Self – Childhood Friend of Damien & Jason (as Jennifer Bearden)

David Burnett as Self – Trial Judge

Stephanie Dollar as Self – Defense Witness - Misskelley Trial

Dennis Carter as Self – Defense Witness - Misskelley Trial

Dennis Riordan as Self – Damien Echols' Attorney

Eddie Vedder as Self – WM3 Supporter

Henry Rollins as Self – WM3 Supporter

Peter Jackson as Self – WM3 Supporter

Michael Carson as Self – Former Juvenile Inmate

Joyce Cureton as Self – Director of Juvenile Detention, Retired

John Douglas as Self – FBI Profiler, Retired

John Mark Byers as Self – Adoptive Father of Christopher Byers

Vicki Hutcheson as Self – Prosecution Witness

Vincent J.M. Di Maio as Self – Forensic Pathologist

Joseph Garner as Self – Neighborhood Friend of the Byers Family

Carlos Seals as Self – Neighborhood Friend of the Byers Family

Jamie Ballard as Self – Neighbor of Stevie Branch

John Richards as Self – Turtle Breeder

Rachael Geiser as Self – Private Investigator

Amanda Hobbs as Self – Stevie Branch's Sister

Robert Heath Meeks as Self – Therapist

Erin Moriarty as Self – Journalist

Don Horgan as Self – Damien Echols' Attorney

Barry Scheck as Self – The Innocence Project

Johnny Depp as Self – WM3 Supporter

Patti Smith as Self – WM3 Supporter

Natalie Maines as Self – WM3 Supporter

Mildred French as Self – Neighbor of Terry Hobbs

Judy Sadler as Self – Stevie Branch's Aunt

Marie Hicks as Self – Stevie Branch's Grandmother

Cindy Hobbs as Self – Terry Hobbs' Sister

David Jacoby as Self – Friend of Terry Hobbs

Sheila Muse as Self – Stevie Branch's Aunt

Stephen Braga as Self – Damien Echols' Attorney

Blake Sisk as Self – Witness #1 - Interview with Rachael Geiser

Cody Gott as Self – Witness #2 - Interview with Rachael Geiser

Capi Peck as Self – Arkansas Take Action

Patrick Benca as Self – Damien Echols' Attorney

Scott Ellington as Self – District Prosecuting Attorney, 2nd JD Arkansas

Holly Ballard as Self – Friend of Jason Baldwin

Gail Grinnell as Self – Jason Baldwin's Mother

Gary Gitchell as Self – West Memphis Police Department (archive footage)

Terry Hobbs as Self – Stevie Branch's Stepfather (archive footage)

Richard Souviron as Self – Forensic Odontologist (archive footage)