Candace Cameron Bure as Aurora Teagarden

Niall Matter as Nick Miller

Marilu Henner as Aida Teagarden

Miranda Frigon as Lynn Smith

Dylan Sloane as Phillip Pifer

Brad Harder as Sergeant Charlie Heard

Ellie Harvie as Lillian Tibbett

Julia Benson as Lizzie

Cole Vigue as Davis Mettle

Kendall Cross as Terry Hall

Ben Cockell as Jacob Hall

Jaycie Dotin as Sharon Patterson

Tyler McClendon as Russ Slocum

Mike Carpenter as Cliff Minton

Mark Gibbon as Donald Heller

Ronald Patrick Thompson as Tom

Lydia Campbell as Holly

Dhirendra as Motel Manager

Nhi Do as Jenna

Brian Cyburt as Brandon