Marlon Wayans as Howard Gordon

Priah Ferguson as Sydney Gordon

Kelly Rowland as Emily Gordon

John Michael Higgins as Principal Floyd

Lauren Lapkus as Mayor Tammy

Rob Riggle as Sully

Nia Vardalos as Madam Hawthorne

Abi Monterey as Ramona

Holly J. Barrett as Jamie

Myles Perez as Mario

Helen Slayton-Hughes as Victoria Hawthorne

Doug Dawson as Stingy Jack Ghost

Pfeiffer Yaeger as Young Victoria

Finn Carmichael as Skeleton Kid

Jonathan Kite as Mr. Skinner

Douglas Hodge as Old Man

Kay Hall as Old Woman

David A. Cooper as Father Ben

Dave Sheridan as Farmer Brown

Keil Oakley Zepernick as Stingy Jack Effigy

Nickolas Wolf as Ringmaster

BJ Guyer as Bat Puppeteer

Chris Thomas Hayes as Skeleton Puppeteer #1

Kiera E. Robbins as Skeleton Puppeteer #2

Molly Coffee as Skeleton Puppeteer #3

Thomas Trinh as Skeleton Puppeteer #4

Mark Steger as Pharaoh Mummy

Gordon Tarpley as High Priest Mummy

Elin Quinn Ponder as Trick or Treat Kid #1

Drew Clavin Farmer as Trick or Treat Kid #2