Stewart Granger as Old Surehand

Pierre Brice as Winnetou

Elke Sommer as Annie Dillman

Götz George as Martin Baumann Jr.

Walter Barnes as Martin Baumann Sr.

Renato Baldini as Judge Leader

Terence Hill as Baker Jr.

Sieghardt Rupp as Preston

Milan Srdoč as Old Wabble

Miha Baloh as 'Reverend' Weller

Louis Velle as Gordon

Gojko Mitić as Wokadeh

Dunja Rajter as Betsy (uncredited)

Voja Mirić as Stewart

Ilija Ivezić as Jackie

Đorđe Nenadović as Miller

Nevenka Benković as Settler woman (uncredited)

Šime Jagarinac as Schoschone (uncredited)