Josh Sharp as Craig

Aaron Jackson as Trevor

Nathan Lane as Harris

Megan Mullally as Evelyn

Bowen Yang as God

Megan Thee Stallion as Gloria

Tom Kenny as Backpack

Frank Todaro as Whisper

Oscar Montoya as Oscar the Garbage Man

Sonya Eddy as Sonya the Old Lady

Blake Daniel as Blake the Mailman

Danielle Perez as Danielle the Stooper

Amy Jo Jackson as Sister Tammy

Nick Offerman as Steve Chaney

D'Arcy Carden as Neighbor

Marius de Vries as Maitre d'

Yoli Lara as Blonde

Desiree Estrada as Brunette

Eric Ritter as Animal Control Guy