Torrey DeVitto as Madison Rush

Zane Holtz as Connor Avery

Shawn Ahmed as Jefferson

Amanda Barker as Edna Prescott

Tanisha Thammavongsa as Hayley

Richard Waugh as Livingston

Jennie Esnard as Judge

Ava Weiss as Beth Prescott

Jonathan Neil Alexander as Sean

Dave Rose as Bookstore Reader

Evert Houston as Historian

Kiera Meeks as Stage Crew

Morgan Saunders as Josie Avery

Yvette McKoy as Sophia Farentino

Shaun Austin-Olsen as Stern Gent

Duane Keogh as Walter

Eddie Bizarria as Town Crier