Meredith Thomas as Sheriff Hudson

Jill Awbrey as The Woman

Gigi Gustin as Tammy Wright (segment "Nite Flirt")

Bill Moseley as The Caller (segment "Nite Flirt")

Sheila Ball as Myra Wright (segment "Nite Flirt")

Stephon Strickland as Ray (segment "You Promised")

Moriah N. Boone as Carol (segment "You Promised")

Jenna Kanell as Lila Cameron (segment "Miniature")

Philip Estrin as Winston

Joseph "Jojo" Martinez as The Boy (segment "We All Scream")

Amber Medina as The Mom (segment "We All Scream")

Mr. Sweetie as Himself (segment "We All Scream")

Gigi Gustin as Marion (segment "Miniature")

Peter Xifo as Janitor (segment "Miniature")

Amber Pauline as Toy (segment "Miniature")

Karma Rx as Toy (segment "Miniature")

Dan Swaney as Toy (segment "Miniature")

Or Mussman as Toy (segment "Miniature")

Jeff Kongs as Toy (segment "Miniature")

Nicholas Adams as Toy (segment "Miniature")

Collin Carter as Toy (segment "Miniature")

Nick Meyer as Toy (segment "Miniature")

Matthew Hersh as Officer Mooney (segment "You Promised")

Nick Nicholson as Jim (segment "You Promised")

Justin Miles as Will (segment "You Promised")

Jessie Allen Hitner as Rob (segment "You Promised")

Allison Victoria-Wolfe as Officer Scully (segment "You Promised")

Tara Price as Officer Starling (segment "You Promised")