Alia Shawkat as Brandi Blackbear

Illeana Douglas as Toni Blackbear

Eric Schweig as Tim Blackbear

Ritchie Montgomery as Henry Bracken

Gary Grubbs as John Mack Butler

Simone Carter as Casey

Lucas Till as Kyle Kenney

Laura Slade Wiggins as Kimberley

Nancy McLoughlin as English Teacher

Rebecca Rose as Millicent

Josh Blaylock as Noah Taylor

J.D. Evermore as Mr. Gray

Douglas M. Griffin as Ken Knox

Nakotah LaRance as Tim Blackbear Jr.

Laurel Whitsett as Sarah Carson

Margo Moorer as Judge Meehan

Juli Erickson as Secretary Mrs. Figgis

Hannah McLoughlin as Frail Looking Girl

Kelvin Payton as Science Teacher

Ann Mahoney as Mrs. Carroll

Renee Caldwell as Math Teacher

Nathan Phillips as Medicine Man

Patrick Kirton as Network Reporter

Veronica Mosgrove as Local TV Reporter

Margaret Lawhon as Reporter At School

Christy Wells as Local Reporter

Amanda Bosley as Christian Protester

Kerry Burnette as Fake Beard Kid

Mellinda Craig as News Reporter

Dustin Estis as High School Student

Ron Fagan as School Counselor

Leah Rose Fisher as High School Student

Richard Harold as Local Reporter

Michael J. Hebert as Resource Officer

Daniel Lachman as High School Student

Lacie Manshack as Party Goer

Jonathan Reynolds as Donkey's Rear End

Cynthia Riser as Christian Protester

Mary Alfred Thoma as John Mack Butler's Wife

Amy Updegraff as Brandi's Friend