Nick Jonas as Renn Wheeland

Brittany Snow as Leigh Wheeland

Alexandra Shipp as Zoey Abbot

David Arquette as Rick Barona

Matt Walsh as Darren Wheeland

Elisabeth Shue as Lily Wheeland

Steve Park as Fr. Dan

Ryan Bergara as Andy

Mason Cufari as Young Renn

Dee Beasnael as Kim

Mimi Gianopulos as Parker

Grey Henson as Sam

Glo Tavarez as Waitress

Rob King as Ticket Agent

Evangeline Johns as Old Woman

Larry Pine as Kevin

Jim C. Ferris as Bill (uncredited)