Peter Paige as Paul Johnson

Kathy Najimy as Maggie Butler

Anthony Clark as Russell Trotter

Lisa Edelstein as Sarah Faber

Jim Ortlieb as David Berman

Gabrielle Union as Elise Carter

Melanie Lynskey as Susan

Katie O’Grady as Mother #1

Ayanna Berkshire as Mother #2

Don Adler as Grant Sweet

Robert Blanche as Phil

Betty Boyer as Clothing Store Lady

Patrick Dizney as Jim Faber

Heidi Herschbach as Perky Receptionist

Beth Harper as Adoption Agency Lady

Joshua Westhaver as Crunchy Man

Leslie Taylor as Screaming Mom

Kevin Jones as Simon's Dad

Marc Anthony Samuel as Keith

Don Burns as Richard Long

Lori Ferraro as Coffee Shop Clerk

Torrey Cornwell as Lesbian Mom

Victor Morris as Police Sergeant

Ellen Bloodworth as Donut Shop Woman

Brian Pope as Joey's Dad

Maia McCarthy as Young Mother

Brooke Blanchard as Leslie

Brooks McCauley as Tyler

Nina Hambleton as Lindsay

Raymond Burney as Simon

Joshua Pope as Joey

Alexandra Morrison as Six-Year-Old Girl

Jacob Reznicki as Jacob

Madeline Dean as Ashley

Sophie Schoenfeld as Kid #1

Tanner Phelps as Timmy