Loren Dean as Billy Bathgate

Dustin Hoffman as Dutch Schultz

Nicole Kidman as Drew Preston

Bruce Willis as Bo Weinberg

Steve Buscemi as Irving

Stanley Tucci as Lucky Luciano

Steven Hill as Otto Berman

Billy Jaye as Mickey

John Costelloe as Lulu

Timothy Jerome as Dixie Davis

Mike Starr as Julie Martin

Robert F. Colesberry as Jack Kelly

Stephen Joyce as Mr. Hines

Frances Conroy as Mary Behan

Moira Kelly as Becky

Kevin Corrigan as Arnold

Rob Kramer as Billy's Gang

Xander Berkeley as Harvey Preston

Katharine Houghton as Charlotte

Jack Mulcahy as Fire Inspector

Kenny Vance as Dutch's Thug