Billy Bob Thornton as Morris Buttermaker

Greg Kinnear as Roy Bullock

Marcia Gay Harden as Liz Whitewood

Sammi Kane Kraft as Amanda Whurlitzer

Ridge Canipe as Toby Whitewood

Brandon Craggs as Mike Engelberg

Jeffrey Davies as Kelly Leak

Timmy Deters as Tanner Boyle

Carlos Estrada as Miguel Agilar

Emmanuel Estrada as Jose Agilar

Troy Gentile as Matthew Hooper

Kenneth 'K.C.' Harris as Ahmad Abdul Rahim

Aman Johal as Prem Lahiri

Tyler Patrick Jones as Timmy Lupus

Jeffrey Tedmori as Garo Daragabrigadien

Carter Jenkins as Joey Bullock

Seth Adkins as Jimmy

Chase Winton as Ms. Cleveland

Arabella Holzbog as Shari Bullock

Nectar Rose as Paradise

Lisa Arturo as Peaches

Lizz Carter as Chandalier

Monique Cooper as Lolita

Candace Kita as China

Kate Luyben as Daisy

Shamron Moore as Cherry Pie

Jeffrey Hutchinson as Baseball Official

Sonya Eddy as Saleslady

Karen-Eileen Gordon as Saleslady

Maura Vincent as Shopper

Jennifer Carta as Softball Player Suzy

Dennis LaValle as Deaver Dad

Robert Peters as Yankee Dad

Kevin R. Kelly as Yankee Dad

Shannon O'Hurley as All American Mom

Hunter Cole as All American Boy

Wil Myer as All American Boy

Pancho Moler as Kevin

Jack Acampora as Yankee Player

Bretton Blayde as Yankee Player

Ryan Cruz as Yankee Player

Nick Lovullo as Yankee Player

Richard Martinez as Yankee Player

Payton Milone as Yankee Player

Ernesto Junior Prado as Yankee Player

Kirby James Shaw as Yankee Player

Cody Ray Thompson as Yankee Player

Hayden Tsutsui as Yankee Player

Matthew Walker as Yankee Player

Darin Rossi as Umpire

Gary Rodriguez as Umpire

Scott Adsit as Umpire

Kevin Makely as Umpire

Robert Wagner as Umpire

Ken Medlock as Umpire

Josh Goldfield as Umpire

Mike Paciorek as Umpire

Jeff Conrad as State Band Member

Sam Farrar as State Band Member

Alex Greenwald as State Band Member

Darren Robinson as State Band Member

Shane Ryan-Reid as Concert Goer