Shea Whigham as Phil

Jonathan Scarfe as Nicholas Brady

Michael Rothhaar as Herb Bennon

Katheryn Winnick as Rachel Brady

Scott Wilson as President Fremont

Julie Warner as Newscaster #1

Bruce Hensel as Newscaster #2

Rosemary Harris as VALIS (voice)

John Prosky as Dr. Goldfarb

Kelly Hare as Fremont House Tour Guide

Jon Tenney as FBI Agent #1

Rich Sommer as FBI Agent #2

Joel McKinnon Miller as Berkeley Detective

Peter Holden as Berkeley Cop

Alanis Morissette as Sylvia Aramchek

Hanna Hall as Vivian Kaplan

Mason Cotton as Ezra Brady

Ashley Greene as Rhonda / Delivery Girl

Hugh Holub as Oral Surgeon

Carol Avery as Jan (Secretary)

Kevin McCorkle as TV Anchorman

Licia L. Shearer as Nurse

Richard Cox as Dr. Weinberg

Robert Dolan as FAP Police Guard #1

Alexander Wells as FAP Police Guard #2

Frank Collison as Leon

Joseph D. Reitman as Prisoner #1

Jason Gray as FAP Militia Man 1

Todd J. Thomas as FAP Militia Man 2

Will Rothhaar as Ted Pollett

Maxwell Perry Cotton as Young Nick (uncredited)

Matt Santoro as White House Photojournalist (uncredited)