Dylan Flashner as Eli

Ariel Winter as Hayley

Vivica A. Fox as Louise

Mayim Bialik as Annabelle Weiss

Dermot Mulroney as Gabe

Jim Klock as Jake

Benjamin Mackey as Sam

Eric Michael Cole as Frankie

Prima Apollinaare as Tzipora

Chris Gann as Officer Daniels

Daniel Lench as Rabbi

Carey James as Bud

John C. Epperson as Bobby

Michael Roddy as Tom

Laura L. Cottrel as Mrs. Moretti

Ronit Aranoff as Mrs. Walker

Mike Capozzi as Mr. Walker

Jonathan Tysor as Gary

Pappy Faulkner as Lonnie

Jonathan Shores as Dennis

Tim Sitarz as Leo

Mayim Bialik as Anabelle Weiss

Coel Mahal as Officer Reece

Tamika Katon-Donegal as Steph

David Moskowitz as Prisoner