Amanda Seyfried as Ann Lee

Lewis Pullman as William Lee

Thomasin McKenzie as Mary Partington / Narrator

Matthew Beard as James Whittaker

Christopher Abbott as Abraham Standerin

Viola Prettejohn as Nancy Lee

David Cale as John Hocknell

Stacy Martin as Jane Wardly

Scott Handy as James Wardley

Jeremy Wheeler as John Townley

Tim Blake Nelson as Pastor Reuben Wight

Daniel Blumberg as Deacon Talmadge Bishop

Willem van der Vegt as Ann's Father

Maria Sand as Ann's Mother

Millie-Rose Crossley as Ann Lee (12 Yrs)

Esmee Hewett as Ann Lee (6 Yrs)

Harry Conway as William Lee (10 Yrs)

Benjamin Bagota as William Lee (4 Yrs)

Scott Alexander Young as Chief Magistrate Tideswell

George Taylor as George Whitefield

Jamie Bogyo as Richard Hocknell

Matti Boustedt as Captain Smith

Alexis Latham as Mr. Cunningham

Shannon Woodward as Mrs. Cunningham

Lark White as Patsy

Roy McCrerey as Mr. Shattuck

Viktória Dányi as Mrs. Shattuck

Natalie Shinnick as Elizabeth Hale

Maddie Browning as Young Mother

Martin O'Regan as Dutchman

Francis McBurney as Infirmary Guard

Alex Gregor as Constable #1

Chris Jackson as Constable #2

Lukas Johne as Jailer

Áron Havasi as Jailer #2

Freya Edmondes as Inmate

Owen Good as Clergyman

James Hogg as Older Deckhand

David Fjällbrant as Young Deckhand #1

Melker Appel as Young Deckhand #2

Laurent Winkler as Builder

Zachary Zamsky as Ruffian #1

Jack LeGoff as Ruffian #2

Maggie Nicols as Townley Woman

Christina Leonardi as Young Shaker Woman

Joseph Foster as Shaker Singer

Sasha Bates as Adam

Mattie Vogler as Eve

Emily Leona Rose as Angel

Vivien Piti as Lewd Woman

Gergely Cserhati as Jacob