Patrick Bauchau as Albert Fish

Jack Conley as Det. Will King

John Aylward as Capt. Ayers

Jillian Armenante as Delia Budd

Silas Weir Mitchell as Albert Fish, Jr.

Vyto Ruginis as Det. Maher

Mollie Milligan as Gertrude

Eric Parker as Edward Budd

Lexi Ainsworth as Grace Budd

Shaun Senter as Pale Boy

Ben Hall as Albert Budd

Brett Bower as Lee Sicowski

Jason Burkhart as John DeMarco

Lisa Carnahan as Maggie

Bill Flynn as Frederic Wertham, M.D.

Shawn Jefferson as Officer Macdonald

Aaron Kozak as Willie

Calley Luman as Gloria DeMarco

Tom Marcantel as Dr. LaGuardia

Cayman Mitchell as Francis McDonnell

Dennis O'Neill as Oscar Downey

Jackson Pace as Billy Gaffney

Wil Rogers as Jimmy

Heather Surdukan as Mrs. Karlson

Paul T. Taylor as Western Union Manager

Laurel Whitsett as Miss Bruce

Austin Majors as Boy Scout (voice)

Colin Anderson as Spanked Boy