Shannon Lucio as Caril-Ann Fugate

Lance Henriksen as The Mentor

Keir O'Donnell as Bob Von Buch

America Young as Barbara Fugate

Brent Taylor as Charles Starkweather

Al Sapienza as Deputy Dale Fahrnbruch

William Frederick Knight as Robert McClurg

Jerry Kroll as Sheriff Merle Karnopp

Steven K. Grabowsky as The Dark Man

Rodney Ballard as Young Charles

George Lindsey Jr. as Guy Starkweather

Justin Ipock as Bobby Colvert

Marianne Emma Jeff as Velda Bartlett

Fred Russell as Marion Bartlett

Sierra Paris as Betty Jean Bartlett