Rufus Sewell as Jacob Brown

Alycia Debnam-Carey as Mary

Adelaide Kane as Ruth

Leah Pipes as Sarah

Thomas McDonell as Trevor

Jennifer Carpenter as Rebekah

Jim McKeny as Elder Stone

Katie Garfield as Abby

Ric Reitz as Sheriff Stevens

Ethan Alexander McGee as Thomas

Jon Stafford as Ruth's Dad

Jane McNeill as Sarah's mother

Holli Saperstein as Midwife

Stacy Rabon as Ruth's Mom

Robin Dale Robertson as Tobias Maker

Nicole Elliott as Hannah

Melissa Lozoff as Hannah's Mom

Stacy Edwards as Susan

Colm Meaney as Elder Beacon

Nichole Amerson as