Gail O'Grady as Susan Parker

Chris Gartin as Andrew Martin

James McDaniel as Wade Thompson

Taylor Cole as Brianna Daniels

Sarah Cote as Laura

Erin Cole as Casey Foreman

Chuck Case III as Courtroom Spectator / Church Mourner

Michael Cognata as Police Officer

Paula Plum as Kathy

Bree Williamson as Debbie Martin

Bates Wilder as George Wilder

Olivia Venuto as Heather Martin

Celeste Oliva as Mary Stone

Georgia Lyman as Leslie Davis

John Kooi as Chief Richards

Tom Kemp as Tom Parker

Katie Iacomini as Kristy Martin

Russell J. Gannon as Church Deacon

Mark DeAngelis as Pastor

Mark Anthony Del Negro as Court Clerk (uncredited)