Paul Schneider as Otto Wall

Anna Camp as Debbie Spangler

Michael Chernus as Freddie

Heather Graham as Stephanie

Ashley Grace as Mildred

Heather Lawless as Lara

Melanie Lynskey as Annie Wall

Audrey P. Scott as Edie Wall

Amy Sedaris as Holly

Celia Weston as Joan

Steve Coulter as Lawyer

Robert Haulbrook as Real Estate Broker

Melcher Smith as Dick

Steven Hall as Doctor

Jeffrey Dean Foster as Greeter at Church

Beth Bostic as Ginny

Ben Baker as Forgotten Man at Reunion (Richard Watts)

Patrice D’Evans as Liz

Mabel Robinson as Liz’s Mother

Sally Meehan as Storyteller at Reunion