Aubrey Plaza as Susan Weber

Parker Posey as Fay Grim

Liam Aiken as Ned Rifle

Robert John Burke as Chet

Martin Donovan as Rev. Daniel Gardner

Karen Sillas as Alice Gardner

James Urbaniak as Simon Grim

Bill Sage as Bud

Jefferson Mays as Dr. Ford

Lloyd Kaufman as Zach

Gia Crovatin as Olive

Quincy Tyler Bernstine as Mary

John Ellison Conlee as Sheriff

Bob Byington as Concierge

Thomas Jay Ryan as Henry Fool

Christina Rouner as Amelia

Johnny M. Wu as Goliath

Paul Boocock as Wilson

Jordan Theodore as Deputy

Tanya Perez as First Guard

Claire Jamison as Correspondent

Tymon Brown as Hospital Orderly

Lindsay Rootare as Laura

Marc Damon Johnson as Anchor Man

Melissa Bithorn as Clair Gardner

Jenny Seastone as Ruth

Andrew Weems as Motel Manager

Jed Feiman as Derek Gardner

Angelo Lozada as Jerry

Penelope Lagos as Elenore

Megan Hartig as Delores

Ella Steinbeck as Bartender

Caleb Hammond as Frank

Brandon Morrissey as Mitch

Hannah Vaughn as Samantha