Lisa Vischer as Junior Asparagus / Aaron (voice)

Mike Nawrocki as Belthasar - Larry / Jerry Gourd / Mai - Jean Claude Pea / Oscar the Polish Caterer (voice)

Phil Vischer as Ben Haramed - Nezzer / Ali - Mr. Lunt / Pa Grape / Melchoir - Bob / Gaspar - Archibald / Bernie - Jimmy Gourd / Oui - Phillipe Pea / Percy Pea (voice)

Dan Anderson as Dad Asparagus / Benjamin (voice)

Emma Watkins as Mom Asparagus / Leah (voice)

Keri Pisapia as Laura Carrot (voice)

Maggie Roberts as Annie (voice)

Miles Fuqua as Baa-Baa / Samson the Donkey / Joshua the Camel (voice)

Gloria Ballard as Choir (voice)

Kurt Heinecke as Choir (voice)

Laura Neutzling as Choir (voice)

Brian K. Roberts as Choir (voice)

Dustin Ballard as Crowd Extra (voice)

Brian Calhoon as Crowd Extra (voice)

Leeeric Fesko as Crowd Extra (voice)

Mike Sofka as Crowd Extra (voice)

Sarah Vorhees Wendel as Crowd Extra (voice)