Amy Gumenick as Natalee Holloway

Tracy Pollan as Beth Holloway-Twitty

Grant Show as Jug Twitty

Catherine Dent as Carol

Natasha Loring as Hayley

Jacques Strydom as Joran Van Der Sloot

Kim Senogles as Justine

Erin Cloytier as Darla

Clayton Evertson as Deepak Kalpoe

Hein De Vries as Satish Kalpoe

Julie Summers as Barbara Waxman

Cokey Falkow as Patrick van Eem

Leigh Bremridge as Diana Peterson

Susan Danford as Maggie

Sean Cameron Michael as Paul van der Sloot

Sean Higgs as Detective Frank Sneider

André Jacobs as Detective Roemer

Bjorn Steinbach as Brent

Wayne Harrison as Dave Holloway