Michael Shannon as John Rosow

Amy Ryan as Miss Charley

Frank Wood as Harold Fullmer

Linda Emond as Megan Fullmer

John Ventimiglia as Hero Furillo

Margaret Colin as Lana Cobb

Paul Sparks as Gus Papitos

Yul Vazquez as Don Edgar

Paul Adelstein as Drexler Hewitt

Liza Weil as Agent Chambers

Daniel Franzese as Agent Craig

Merritt Wever as Mabel Page

Gary Wilmes as Eric Jelin

Kate Arrington as Jane Rosow

Coati Mundi as Fernando Guerrero

Charles Socarides as Young Doorman (John Stockton)

Steven Marcus as Jim Kaat

James A. Stephens as Old Doorman (Alex Patton)