Dana Andrews as Thomas Roth

Farley Granger as Martin Lynn

Joan Evans as Rita Conroy

Robert Keith as Mandel

Paul Stewart as Mr. Craig

Mala Powers as Julie

Adele Jergens as Irene

Harold Vermilyea as Father Kirkman

John Ridgely as Detective #1

Douglas Fowley as Detective #2

Mabel Paige as Mrs. Pearson

Howland Chamberlain as Mr. Murray

Houseley Stevenson as Mr. Swanson

Jean Inness as Mrs. Lally

Ellen Corby as Jeanette Moore

Ray Teal as Ned Moore

Mary Field as Mary Jane Glennon

Virginia Brissac as Mrs. Dennis

Frances Morris as Mrs. Lynn

Bess Flowers as Flower Shop Customer (uncredited)