Lex Barker as Old Shatterhand

Pierre Brice as Winnetou

Anthony Steel as Bud Forester

Karin Dor as Ribanna

Klaus Kinski as David "Luke" Lucas

Renato Baldini as Colonel J.F. Merril

Terence Hill as Lieutenant Robert Merril

Marie-Noëlle Barre as Susan Merril

Eddi Arent as Lord Castlepool

Gojko Mitić as White Bird (uncredited)

Ilija Ivezić as Red

Velimir Chytil as Carter

Stole Aranđelović as Caesar

Đorđe Nenadović as Capt. Bruce

Mirko Boman as Gunstick Uncle

Rikard Brzeska as Tah-Sha-Tunga

Curt Ackermann as Narrator (voice) (uncredited)

Jozo Kovačević as Ponca Chief (uncredited)